The 1976 Trenton Extension team had 6 future NASL players (Highlighted in yellow).  They lost the 1976 National Amateur Cup Championship to the Milwaukee Bavarians.  That must have been quite a game.
FR: Tim Murphy, player-coach Charlie Farutto, John Marsden, Rich Reice, Bill Gazonas, Dennis Kinnevy
BR: Barry Pellitteri, Glenn Myernick, Bob Rostron, Jim McKeown, Joe Hankins, Kevin Costello, coach Joe Secretario, Art Napolitano
Photo from http://www.flickr.com/