| Paul Toomey Born: New London, Connecticut, August 28, 1956 College: University of Pennsylvania |
 |
Team | League | Year | Num | Pos | Games | Goals | Assists | Points | Citizen |
| Portland Timbers | NASL | 79 | 9 | D | 8 | 0 | 0 | 0 | USA | |
| Hartford Hellions | MISL | 79-80 | 5 | D | 32 | 1 | 7 | 8 | USA | |
| San Jose Earthquakes | NASL | 80 | 13 | D | 17 | 0 | 0 | 0 | USA | |
| Hartford Hellions | MISL | 80-81 | 5 | D | 25 | 6 | 5 | 11 | USA | |
| New England Sharks | ASL | 81 | D | USA | ||||||
| Pittsburgh Spirit | MISL | 81-82 | 7 | D | 52 | 5 | 14 | 19 | USA | |
| Pittsburgh Spirit | MISL | 82-83 | 7 | D | 43 | 5 | 4 | 9 | USA | |
| Pittsburgh Spirit | MISL | 83-84 | 7 | D | 12 | 0 | 2 | 2 | USA | |
| Portland Timbers 1979 Home |
| Portland Timbers 1979 Road |
| Hartford Hellions 1979-80 Home (MISL) |
 |
| Hartford Hellions 1979-80 Road (MISL) |
| San Jose Earthquakes 1980 Home |
 Paul Toomey (13), Andries Maseko (23), Robbie Rensenbrink (19), Gary Ayre (13) San Jose Earthquakes at Portland Timbers |
| San Jose Earthquakes 1980 Road |
| Hartford Hellions 1980-81 Home (MISL) |
 |
| Hartford Hellions 1980-81 Road (MISL) |
| Pittsburgh Spirit 1981-82 Home (MISL) |
| Pittsburgh Spirit 1981-82 Road (MISL) |
| Pittsburgh Spirit 1982-83 Home (MISL) |
 |
| Pittsburgh Spirit 1982-83 Road (MISL) |
 |
| Pittsburgh Spirit 1983-84 Home (MISL) |
| Pittsburgh Spirit 1983-84 Road (MISL) |